Read what some of our satisfied insurance customers have to say! If you’d like to provide your feedback, please submit your online review.
- MAEagle Rock, VACustomer since Jun 2008
“I’ve had an account with Andy from the beginning of his Insurance career. He worked for another company and would visit my elementary school.
I’ve always been satisfied and confident in the decisions he’s made. ” - JMLynchburg, VACustomer since Oct 2014
“Office staff answer calls quickly and resolve issues in a timely manner. Staff is friendly and personable. Rates are good for insurance.”
- JSAnonymous, Brookneal, VACustomer since May 2019
“You saved me a lot of money on my car insurance. ”
- WLAnonymous, Lynchburg, VACustomer since Feb 2014
“Andy has been great in handling all my insurance. The people working for him are responsible and very helpful with all my insurance needs. I recommend Andy to anyone who needs a good insurance plan. ”
- JDAnonymous, Scottsburg, VACustomer since Jun 2014
“I’ve been purchasing car insurance since the 1980s. This is the first year that I have ever called in a claim. AM made it more simple than I thought possible. Vehicle replaced while In The shop. Back with us in less than a week. We were impressed. ”
- WDAnonymous, Floyd, VACustomer since Nov 2005
“They show up almost immediately when there’s been an accident (example: When preacher’s truck rolled down the hill & hit my kitchen.)
They pay up. (I got a check for towing within a week of submitting it.)
They can beat anyone else’s prices. I’ve been with them since the ’90s”
- KSAnonymous, Madison Heights, VACustomer since Mar 2012
“Michael and Carla are the best. I have been an Erie client for home and auto for many years and the coverage and cost for coverage can’t be beat. Service is amazing as well.
Thank you,
Kim” - SRWilmington, NCCustomer since Jul 2015
“We have worked with Mary Bomar for several years. She was recommended to us by a family member, and is always prompt, courteous and professional.”
- MCEvington, VACustomer since Jun 2016
“I’ve recommended you all several times. You are professional, quick, and, knowledgeable about what’s available. Although I havent always been notified when my policy was being handled by another agent, it’s always quickly resolved when I have questions. I am highly satisfied with my coverage and my business with your agency. ”
- DFLynchburg, VACustomer since Aug 2014
“Your responses are always so quick and detailed, which I really appreciate. ”
- JA
“Just keep up the excellent services you all provide.”
- DL
“Andy has a wonderful personality, I feel as if he is one of our family. I would recommend his insurance policies to anyone. I am glad he was recommended to me years ago.”
- BM
“I would never go anywhere else as long as Wendy is there. She is the best agent ever and an overalls great person. We just love her. We think of her as family.”
- DR
“Wendy and the staff at Andy Mathews Agency have always been not only professional and courteous, but made me and my family feel like they are part of our family. Through our work with the agency, we have come to know most of the employees, and every time I step through the door I feel welcome and like I am their most important customer. I only wish more business’s in our connected society embodied the same vision and mission as the Andy Mathews Agency. ”
- AR
“Great rates and quick response! ”